Welcome to Dr. Laurence Packer's Webpage

Journal Abstracts

A63 Zayed, A. and Packer, L. 2001. High levels of diploid male production in a primitively eusocial bee (Hymenoptera: Halictidae). Heredity. 87:631-636.
Abstract

Under single locus complementary sex determination (sl-CSD), diploid males are produced from fertilized eggs that are homozygous at the sex-determining locus. Diploid males are effectively sterile, and thus their production generates a costly genetic load. Using allozyme electrophoresis, a large number of diploid males were detected in natural populations of the primitively eusocial bee, Halictus poeyi Lepeletier collected in southern and central Florida during May 2000. Estimates for the proportion of diploids that are male ranged from 9.1% to 50%, while the frequency of matched matings ranged from 18.2% to 100%. The effective number of alleles at the sex-determining locus ranged from 2 to 11, with an average of 5 alleles. The effective population size of Halictus poeyi was estimated to be 19.6 ± 2.5 S.E. These data are interpreted in the light of the biogeographic history of Florida and the social biology/population dynamics of H. poeyi.

 

A62 Packer, L. and R. Owen. 2001. Population genetic aspects of pollinator decline. Conservation Ecology 5(1): 4. [online] URL: http://www.consecol.org/vol5/iss1/art4
Abstract

We reviewed the theory of conservation genetics, with special emphasis on the influence of haplodiploidy and other aspects of bee biology upon conservation genetic parameters. We then investigated the possibility that pollinator decline can be addressed in this way, using two meta-analytical approaches on genetic data from the Hymenoptera and the Lepidoptera. First, we compared levels of heterozygosity between the orders. As has been found previously, the haplodiploid Hymenoptera had markedly lower levels of genetic variation than the Lepidoptera. Bees had even lower levels, and bumble bees, in particular, often seemed almost monomorphic genetically. However, the statistically confounding effects of phylogeny render detailed interpretation of such data difficult. Second, we investigated patterns of gene flow among populations of these insects. Hymenoptera were far more likely to show genetic effects of population fragmentation than are Lepidoptera, even at similar geographic distances between populations. The reduced effective population sizes resulting from haplodiploidy probably contributed to this result. The proportion of species with low levels of gene flow did not vary among the different taxonomic groups within the Hymenoptera.

 

A61 Pabalan, N., Davey, K.G., and Packer, L. 2000. Escalation of aggressive interactions during staged encouters in Halictus ligatus Say (Hymenoptera: Halictidae), with a comparison of circle tube behaviors with other Halictine species'. Journal of Insect Behavior. 13:627-650
Abstract

Circle tube experiments on the primitively eusocial bee, Halictus ligatus, were performed for a variety of combinations of caste and size. Push, Lunge, and Back without reverse behaviors enabled us to determine the dominant individual in most comparisons. Behavioral differences were readily detected within the first 15 min. except for different-size forager-forager and same-size foundress-foundress pairs, for which 30 min of observations was required. In same-size forager-forager pairs, no differences in behaviors between individuals were detected even after 90 min. In extended observations, decreases in the frequency of the mild dominant behaviors were accompanied by a switch to the highly aggressive mandibular hold on the neck, particularly in different-size foundress-foundress and gyne-gyne paris. Three workers were killed by their own queen as a result of this escalation of aggression. We discuss caste-based differences in the circle tube setting in terms of behaviors expected under more normal conditions and compare our data with published results from other species.

 

A60 Plateaux-Quénu, C., L. Plateaux and L. Packer. 2000. Population-typical behavious are retained when eusocial and non-eusocial forms of Evylaeus albipes (F.) (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) are reared simultaneously in the laboratory. Insectes Sociaux. 47:263-270
Abstract

We compare the behaviour of daughters of Evylaeus albipes females from eusocial populations from the West of France with those from a non-eusocial population from the East of the country. When non-eusocial population females are placed in the laboratory under day lengths and temperature conditions similar to those experienced by eusocial foundresses under natural conditions, all five produced a brood of males and overwintering daughters with no workers. When 18 nests were initiated by non-eusocial foundresses under short summer daylenghts but warmer than normal temperatures, two produced one worker amongst overwintering female and male brood. Both worker-producing non-eusocial females were from the warmest of the eastern localities. When foundresses of the social population are placed under day length conditions typical for the non-eusocial population but with temperature conditions that are intermediate between the two, all five produced at least one worker. Similarly, if the first brood produced by social foundresses is removed, they raise another brood that contains workers whereas non-eusocial population foundresses who have their first brood removed produce a second brood of overwintering females (although one foundress, again from the warmest of the non-eusocial localities, produced one worker in each of two broods, also with males and overwintering females). We conclude that i) non-eusocial foundresses do not readily produce workers under long summer conditions; ii) the lack of worker production by most non-eusocial population females is not because they cannot produce two broods, but because they have a tendency not to produce workers; iii) eusocial population daughters will become active without diapausing in the presence of any other female - even of the closely related E. calceatus, unless the first individual to eclose is the smallest and iv) social population foundresses are incapable of producing over-wintering females without the help of workers. These data show an interesting combination of flexibility and constraint on social behaviour in these bees.

 

A59 Kerr, J.T., Sugar, A., and Packer, L. 2000. Indicator taxa, rapid biodiversity assement, and nestedness in an endangered ecosystem. Conservation Biology. 14:1726-1734.
Abstract

To prioritize areas for conservation, biologists and mangers need information on species diversity in threatened habitats. The resources available for such inventories remain severly limited, increasing the need to develop speedier ways to estimate the status of target habitats. We present a study of the use of such techniques in the highly fragmented oak savannas of southern Ontario, including selection of indicator taxa, use of rapid biodivesity assessment based on morphospecies, and analysis of community structure. We found that butterflies and skippers can be used to predict richness among Hymenoptera in the study sites, which is consistent with the byopthesis that these easily surveyed Lipidoptera are good candidates for indicator status. Richness values for bymemoptera morphospecies in these savanna remnants were strongly correlated with species richness scores as estimated by systematists, although nonspecialists tended to spilt into more than one morphospecies. Finally, both the Hymenoptera and Lepidoptera communities in these oak savannas exhibited a high degree of nestedness, suggesting that local extinctions, mostly undocumented, are important determinants of the richness patterns across these widely separated savanna study sites. We found no evidence of significant spatial autocorrelation, probably because of the wide separation of study sites.

 

A58 Packer, L. 2000. The biology of Thrincohalictus prognathus (Perez) (Hymenoptera: Halictidae: Halictini). J. Hym. Res. 9:53-61.
Abstract

The Halictine bee Thrinchalictus prognathus (Perez) was studied in Israel in May and the beginning of June, 1998. Additional information was obtained from museum specimens. The species appears to be both common and widespread in northern Israel, paticularly in the Galilee and Golan Heights where it occurs between altitudes of several hundred metres up to 1650m on Mount Hermon. Despite having an unsually elongate head, the species visits a wide range of flowers which generally do not possess a long corolla. Like most temperate halictines, only mated females overwinter and become active in the spring, as early as mid March. Males are found no earlier than mid May. The apparent age of females increases from March to May with newly eclosed, unworm individuals appearing in late May/early June. All worn early summer individuals were mated and had well developed ovaries. Thus, ovarian development and phenological data are inconsistent with the species being eusocial but are consistent with it being univoltine. The behaviour exhibited by paired females in artifical obervation arenas indicates that T. prognathus possesses the repertoire of agonistic and cooperative behaviours usually found in halictines but that aggressive interactions predominate. Comparisons with other species indicate that the relative frequency of passing behaviour is very low and inconsistent with that expected for a communal species. I conclude that this species is probably solitary.

 

A57 Kerr, J.T. and Packer, L. 1999. The environmental basis of North American species richness patterns among Epicuata (Coleoptera: Meloidae). Biodiversity and Conservation. 8:617-628.
Abstract

Understanding regional variability in species richness is necessary for conservation efforts to succeed in the face of large-scale environmental deterioration. Several analyses of North American vertebrates have shown that climatic energy provides the best explanation of contemporary species richness patterns. The paucity of analyses of insect diversity patterns, however, remains a serious obstacle to a general hypothesis of spatial variation in diversity. We collected species distribution data on a North American beetle genus, Epicauta (Coleoptera: Meloidae) and tested several major diversity hypotheses. These beetles are generally grasshopper egg predators as larvae, and angiosperm herbivores as adults. Epicauta richness is highest in the hot, dry American southwest, and decreases north and east, consistent with the species richness-energy hypothesis. Potential evapotranspiration, which is also the best predictor of richness patterns among North American vertebrates, explains 80.2% of the variability in Epicauta species richness. Net primary productivity and variables measuring climatic heat energy only (such as PET) are not generally comparable, though they are sometimes treated as if they were equivalent. We conclude that the species richness-energy hypothesis currently provides a better overall explanation for Epicauta species richness pattern in North America than other major diversity hypothesis. The observed relationship between climatic energy and regional species richness may provide significant insight into the response of ecological communities to climate change.

 

A56 Danforth, B.N., H. Sauquet and L. Packer, 1999. Phylogeny of the bee genus Halictus (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) based on parsimony and likelihood analyses of nuclear EF-1 alpha sequence data. Molecular phylogenetics and Evolution. 13:605-618.
Abstract

We investigated higher-level phylogenetic relationships within the genus Halictus based on parsimony and maximum likelihood (ML) analysis of elongation factor-1a DNA sequence data. Our data set includes 41 OTUs representing 35 species of halictine bees from a diverse sample of outgroup genera and from the three widely recognized subgenera of Halictus (Halictus s.s., Seladonia, and Vestitohalictus). We analyzed 1513 total aligned nucleotide sites spanning three exons and two introns. Equal-weights parsimony analysis of the over- all data set yielded 144 equally parsomonious trees. Major conclusions supported in this analysis (and in all subsequent analyses) included the following: (1) Thrinchalictus is the sister group to Halictus s.l., (2) Halictus s.1. is monophyletic, (3) Vestitohalictus renders Seladonia paraphyletic but together Seladonia + Vestitohalictus is monophyletic, (4) Michener's Groups 1 and 3 are monophyletic, and (5) Michener's Group 1 renders Group 2 paraphyletic. In order to resolve basal relationships within Halictus we applied various weighting schemes under parsimony (successive approximations character weighting and implied weights) and employed ML under 17 models of sequence evolution. Weighted parsimony yielded conflicting results but, in general, supported the hypothesis that Seladonia + Vestitohalictus is sister to Michener's Group 3 and renders Halictus s.s. paraphyletic. ML analyses using the GTR model with site-specific rates supported an alternative hypothesis: Seladonia + Vestitohalictus is sister to Halictus s.s. We mapped social behavior onto trees obtained under ML and parsimony in order to reconstruct the likely historical pattern of social evolution. Our results are unambiguous: The ancestral state for the genus Halictus is eusociality. Reversal to solitary behavior has occurred at least four times among the species included in our analysis.

 

A55 Packer, L. 1999. The distribution of Halictus ligatus Say and H. poeyi Lep. (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) in North America. in Byers, G.W.R., Hagen, R.H., and Brooks, R.W. (eds). Entomological Contributions in Memory of Byron A. Alexander. University of Kansas Nature History Museum Special Publication. 24:81-84.
Abstract

Based upon additional sampling, it is demonstrated that Halictus poeyi is found in the southeastern USA, along the coastal plains as far north as Richmond Virginia and along the Gulf Coast at least as far west as Galveston, Texas. Halictus ligatus is found to the north and west of these areas with the species being sympatric throughout the Piedmont.

 

A54 Packer, L. A. Porsa, C. Plateaux-Quénu and L. Plateaux. 1999 A cryptic species allied to Evylaeus villosulus (Kirby) (Hymenoptera: Halictidae). Annales de la Société Entomologique de France. 35: 165-171
Abstract

Giant and normal-sized samples of the Halictine bee Evylaeus villosuius (Kirby) were scored for 41 allozyme loci. An additional sample of normal sized bees was scored for 33 loci. Genetic differentiation between the two normal sized samples was very small and well within the range expected for conspecific populations. In contrast, there was substantial genetic differentiation between the giant and normal sized bees with 5 fixed differences, 3 loci had almost fixed differences and an additional 8 showed significant allele frequency differences. We conclude that what has previously been referred to as a giant form of E. villosulus actually represents an undescribed species. The new species is known only from a few locatities in France, Germany, Austria, Poland and Switzerland whereas the normal size species is much more widespread. The giant bees had the highest heterozygosity of any of our samples indeed, it has one of the highest heterozygosities of any hymenopterous. This suggests that it has not originated recently as a result of some bottleneck effect.

 

A53 Kerr, J.T., and L. Packer. 1999 Epicauta species richness patterns: the importance of energy. Biodiversity and Conservation. 8: 617-628.
Abstract

Understanding regional variability in species richness is necessary for conservation efforts to succeed in the face of large-scale environmental deterioration. Several analyses of North American vertebrates have shown that climatic energy provides the best explanation of contemporary species richness patterns. The paucity of analyses of insect diversity patterns, however, remains a serious obstacle to a general hypothesis of spatial variation in diversity. We collected species distribution data on a North American beetle genus, Epicauta (Coleoptera: Meloidae) and tested several major diversity hypotheses. These beetles are generally grasshopper egg predators as larvae, and angiosperm herbivores as adults. Epicauta richness is highest in the hot, dry American southwest, and decreases north and east, consistent with the species richness-energy hypothesis. Potential evapotranspiration, which is also the best predictor of richness patterns among North American vertebrates, explains 80.2% of the variability in Epicauta species richness. Net primary productivity and variables measuring climatic heat energy only (such as PET) are not generally comparable, though they are sometimes treated as if they were equivalent. We conclude that the species richness-energy hypothesis currently provides a better overall explanation for Epicauta species richness patterns in North America than other major diversity hypotheses. The observed relationship between climatic energy and regional species richness may provide significant insight into the response of ecological communities to climate change.

 

A52 Sugar, A., A. Finamore, H. Goulet, J. Cumming, J.T. Kerr and L. Packer. 1998. A preliminary survey of Symphytan and Aculeate Hymenoptera from oak savannahs in Southern Ontario. Proceedings of the Entomological Society of Ontario. 129: 9-18.
Abstract

The sawflies and aculeate Hymenoptera collected from eight malaise traps placed in oak savannah and three in nearby non-savannah habitat for the end of August, 1994 are listed. A total of 145 species were found in the oak savannah traps. The possibility that some of the taxa discovered are oak savannah specialists is discussed. Six species sampled appear to represent first Canadian records and an additional ten species, sampled from the same sites but outside of the time frame analyzed here, are also recorded as new for Canada. Two additional extralimital records are presented for prairie insects recorded East of Manitoba for the first time.

 

A51 Dunn, M., P.L. Mitchell and L. Packer. 1998. A comparison of the phenology and social biology of two sibling species of Halictus in an area of sympatry. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 76: 2207-2213.
Abstract

Fortnightly samples of foragers of Halictus ligatus say and its recently distinguished sibling species Halictus poeyi Lepeletier were collected in an area of sympatry. Both species were active from late April until autumn, although H. ligatus ceased foraging about 1 month earlier than H. poeyi. Phenological differences were minor and insufficient to preclude hybridization opportunities between the species. The two had a similar proportion and ovarially developed workers, but the proportion that mated in H. poeyi was double that found in H. ligatus, and size dimorphism between castes was greater in H. poeyi than in H. ligatus. When these data are compared with data from other populations, in sympatry the two species appear to be more similar to each other in several sociobiological parameters than each does to allopatric conspecific populations. This suggests a prime role for ecological factors in determining details of social organization in halictine bees.

 

A50 Packer, L. 1998 A phylogenetic analysis of western European species of the Lasioglossum leucozonium species group (Hymenoptera: Halictidae): Sociobiological and taxonomic implications. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 76: 1611-1621.
Abstract

A data matrix of 81 characters for 23 species of the subgenus Lasioglossum sensu Michener (1999) is analysed cladistically with the primary purpose of obtaining a phylogeny for western European species of the Lasioglossum leucozonium group. Outgroup taxa were chosen on the basis of published species groupings for Old World species and a phylogeny for the New World species. Outgroup resolution was poor but results for the in group were consistent and indicate that (i) the social behaviour recorded for L. aegyptiellum is nested within a solitary background and therefore represents an origin of sociality independent of all others within the Halictidae, (ii) the monotypic subgenus Sericohalictus is a derived member of the leucozonium species-group, and (iii) L. laevigatum is not a member of this group.

 

A49 Danforth, B.N., P.L. Mitchell and L. Packer. 1998 Mitochondrial DNA differentiation between two cryptic Halictus (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) species. Annals of the Entomological Society of America. 91: 387-391
Abstract

Halictus ligatus Say and its cryptic sibling species. H. poeyi Lepeletier were sampled from an area of sympatry and typed fro mitochondrial DNA sequence differentiation, as was I individual of each species from allopatric populations. Two other species, H. rubicundus (Christ) and H. farinous Smith, were included to root the tree. Phylogenetic analysis of the aligned sequences showed that H. ligatus and H. poeyi are sister species and differ form each other at 33 of the 797 aligned nucleotide positions. Sequence divergence within species was <0.6%, whereas that between species exceeded 4%. These data support an earlier report that H. ligatus and H. poeyi represent distinct species (based on nuclear allozyme markers) and are sufficient to cast doubt on a recent glaciation-induced speciation event as the cause of the differentiation of these 2 taxa.

 

A48 Packer, L., J. Taylor, D. Savignano, C. Bleser, C. Lane, and L. Sommers. 1998 Population biology of an endangered butterfly, Lycaeides melissa samuelis (Lepidoptera; Lycaenidae): Genetic variation, gene flow and taxonomic status. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 76:320-329
Abstract

We present data from 34 allozyme loci to test whether the Karner Blue butterfly is specifically differentiated from the Melissa Blue. Furthermore, as the Kaner Blue is an endangered organism of low vagility that occurs predominantly in small, widely separated populations, we investigated (i) whether the Karner Blue is depauperate in genetic variation and (ii) whether gene flow between sampled populations is unusually low. Genetic identities between New York and Wisconsin populations of the Karner Blue and a sample of Melissa Blue from Minnesota are all statistically indistinguishable. Neither genetic identity data nor application of the phylogenetic species concept support formal recognition of the Karner Blue as a species separate from the Melissa Blue. Nonetheless, the data indicate that gene flow among the samples was very low compared with that among populations of other Lepidoptera. Heterozygosity estimates for all three samples were comparable to data for other Lepidoptera and indicate that the Karner Blue populations surveyed are not under immediate threat of extipation due to loss of genetic diversity, Although the available data are limited, if the Karner Blue is to be managed as an evolutionarily significant unit, then the eastern and western populations should probaby be treated independently and each should receive high conservation priority.

 

A47 Richards, M.H. and L. Packer 1998. Demography and relatedness in multiple foundress nests of the social sweat bee: Halictus ligatus. Insectes Sociaux. 45: 97-109.
Abstract

Female sweat bees in the species Halictus ligatus exhibit a wide range of reproductive roles, ranging from typically foundress or queen-like to typically worker-like. Nests are founded in spring and most are haplometrotic, that is founded by a single foundress. A few (up to 12%) are pleometrotic, founded by 2-6 foundresses. Variation in the proportion of mulifundress nests from year to year and from place to place sugguests an adaptive basis for pleometrosis. We studied the demographic and social characteristics of 23 pleometrotic nests in an aggregation of 250-300 nests near Victoria, Ontario, in 1984, 1990, and 1991. In pleometrotic associations, dominant foundresses behaved in a manner typical of mid-summer, haplometrotic queens, while subordinates behaved like mid-summer workers. Dominant foundresses tended to be larger that subordinates. Pleometrotic nests were significantly more likely than haplometrotic nests to produce brood, and they also produced more workers. However, this early advantage did not result in the production of more reproductive brood per nest, nor did pleometrotic foundresses experience higher productiivity per foundress than did haplometrotic foundresses. Relatively low relatedness among various categories of brood implied that subordinate foundresses were not closely related to dominants. We suggest that pleometrosis most likely results from accidental encounters between spring foundresses as they leave their hibernacula. Once formed,such assoications confer a survival advantage on the nest as a whole, but do not result in greater reproductive brood productivity.


A46 Plateaux-Quénu, C., L. Plateaux and L. Packer 1998. A test of the mating limitation hypothesis in Evylaeus albipes, a primitively eusocial halictine bee. Journal of Insect Behavior. 11:119-128.
Abstract

Yanega's (1997) mating limitation hypothesis (MLH) states that "if a female mates promptly after emerging, she then becomes a member of the maximally reproductive behavioral caste" (i.e., in most cases an overwintering gyne). Females that do not mate early become workers. We tested the MLH in laboratory colonies of a eusocial population of Evylaeus albipes. Of 24 worker brood females (13 from queenright and 11 from orphaned nests), 13 mated on the first day of flight activity and all mated within the first 5 days; there were no significant differences between mating rates of females from the two colony types. All 24 commenced foraging as workers after an average of between 3 and 4 days postmating. We conclude that the MLH does not apply to this species despite the fact that the only known halictine for which this hypothesis has been experimentally tested is the fairly closely related E. marginatus.

 

A45 Kerr, J. T. and L. Packer 1998. Effects of climate change on Canadian mammal species richness. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. 49: 263-270.
Abstract

Current large-scale mammalian diversity patterns in Canada can be accurately explained using various measurement of heat energy. Unfortunately, climatic change is predicted to alter the fundamental climatic basis for contemporary diversity gradients, with the expected consequence that much of the Canadian biota will need to migrate in order to remain within climatically suitable regions. We make predictions regarding future mammal diversity patterns in Canada, and therefore provide a preliminary indication of where management intervention should be directed in order to conserve mammal diversity as climate changes. We also examine the current distributions of individual mammal species in Canada in order to determine which taxa cannot migrate farther north because of the Arctic Ocean barrier. Of the 25 species that fall into this category, we examine the predicted loss habitat in one keystone species - Decrostonyx groenlandicus, the collared lemming - and find that this taxon is likely to lose approximately 60% of its habitat with unpredictable but likely detrimental consequences for the arctic biota. We discuss the implications of our findings briefly.

 

A44 Packer, L. and J. Taylor 1997. How many hidden species are there? An application of the phylogenetic species concept to genetic data for some comparatively well known bee species. Canadian Entomologist. 129:587-594.
Abstract

Estimates of global species richness for insects are based upon extrapolations from " Known" to unknown faunas and hence rely upon accurate counts of species for the referrent taxon or region. The number of reference species depends upon the species concepts employed by workers in that group combined with the degree to which nonstandard (i.e. nonmorphological) approaches have been used. Genetic data are more directly applicable to the detection of the apparent absence of gene flow, which lies at the heart of any species concept, than is morphological information. But what criteria can be used as a practical guide to suggest the absence for gene flow and define species-level units? Minimally, the phylogenetic species concept requires that there be one fixed difference between two samples for them both to be considered discrete species. The assumptions accompying this definition include the survey for sufficient geographic locations, loci, and individuals. Based upon six studies of mostly widespead, readily identifiable and well-investigated bee "species", we estimate that the number of species currenlty recognised may underestimate the true figure by half (although for at least two of the studies localities have been undersampled and more collections are needed). Even when examples for which there are fewer than five fixed differences between samples are removed from the data set, the number of recognised species increases by perhaps as much as 50% (the same caveat regarding undersampling of populations still applies). We suggest that the presence of morpholoically unrecognised species may be more common among widespread, easily identified "species" than is generally accepted. Whether or not similar levels of species underestimation apply to other faunas, such as tropical rainforest canopy beetles, remains to be investigated.

 

A43

Kerr, J.T. and L. Packer 1997. Habitat heterogeneity determines mammalian species richness in high energy environments. Nature. 385:252-254.
Abstract

A fundamental problem in ecological research is to explain largescale gradients in species richness. Although many causative agents for this phenomenon have been suggested, the species richness-energy hypothesis has received the strongest empirical support: this hypothesis states that higher energy availability provides a broader resource base, permitting more species to coexist. Here we show that the species richness-energy hypothesis applies to North American mammals only over a limited geographical area in which climatic energy levels are low (Alaska and most of Canada), rather than on a continental scale as had previously been accetped. In relatively high-energy regions of North America, corresponding to most of the continental United States and southern Canada, we find that manmal species richness is best predicted by topographic heterogeneity and local variation in energy availability. Our results contradict previous studies of large-scale richness patterns that dismissed the importance of habitat heterogeneity and have implications for climate change research.


A42 Packer, L. 1997. The relevance of phylogenetic systematics to biology: examples from medicine and behavioural ecology. Mémoires de Muséum National d'Histoire Naturelle special volume: The origin of biodiversity in insects: phylogenetic tests of evolutionary scenarios. P. Grandcolas (Ed.) 173:11-29.
Abstract

Results of phylogenetic analysis are frequently used to investigate the pattern of evolution of characteristics of interest. In examples such as the evolution of spider webs, the number of horns on a rhinoceros or social behavior in halictine bees, the results of phylogenetic tests may lead to traditional views being overturned. However, conclusions based upon phylogenetic analyses of evolutionary pattern require careful consideration of character coding and taxonomic sampling as indicated by studies of rhinos and HIV respectively. Phylogenetic results are less often used to direct further research, an area of their application which remains underutilized. In this paper I concentrate on the application of phylogenetics to problems of social evolution in halictine bees. There are seven genera/subgenera that are known to contain both solitary and social species and at least 9 species which exhibit behavioral polymorphism with both solitary behavior and eusociality found within the same or different populations. A priori, these taxa would seem to be the best ones to use in tests of the selective advantages of eusociality. However, results of phylogenetic analysis indicate that in the majority of cases (Halictus, Seladonia, Augochlorella and Augochlora) it is solitary behavior that is the recent evolutionary innovation and eusociality is ancestral. Use of the non-phylogenetic approach to the comparative method in each of these instances would not provide information on origins of eusociality. In contrast, eusociality appears to be derived in both the subgenera Lasioglossum (in the species L. aegyptiellum for which the limited field-collected data are presented for the first time) and Evylaeus. Overall, of the nine species for which both eusociality and solitary behavior have been recorded, solitary behavior is the recent acquisition in at least 6 cases, and the only probable case of recent origin of eusociality exhibited by behaviorally polymorphic species (Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) comagenense and L. (E.) fratellum) refers to origin of delayed eusociality. The application of phylogenetic methods to the study of evolutionary pattern suggests both which taxa are deserving of further field work and which require additional phylogenetic analysis.

 

A41

Carman, G.M. and L. Packer 1997. A cryptic species allied to Halictus ligatus Say. (Hymenoptera; Halictidae). detected by allozyme electrophoresis, G.C. Eickwort Memorial Volume. Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society. 69:168-176.
Abstract

The social biology of Halictus ligatus has been investigated in many localities from Southern Canada to the Caribbean. In southern Florida it seems to be multivoltine and continuously brooded unlike the situation in more northerly areas where it has a more typical annual colony cycle with a moderately well established reproductive division of labor. In order to investigate the possibility of genetic differentiation between southern and northern behavioral types, samples of this species were collected along a transect from Toronto, Ontario in the north, to the Florida Keys in the South; additional samples were available from New Mexico and California. Two distinct species were found but surprisingly, their geographical ranges about far to the north of the behavioral disjunction. The two species are differentiated by no fewer than 7 fixed differences out of 34 loci surveyed using standard gel electrophorectic techniques. It is probable that true H. ligatus is the northern form and that the Southeastern species should be called either H. poeyi Lepeletier or H. capitosus Smith. The two species are sympatric along a narrow stretch around the southern end of the Appalachian Mountains. Several biogeographic hypothese are suggested which may account for the distribution of these two taxa. Further samples are required from the Southern USA, Central America and the Caribbean to differentiate these hpotheses. Comparisons of the social biology of these two species in an area of sympatry should be performed.

 

A40 Richards, M.H. and L. Packer. 1996. The socioecology of body size variation in a primitively eusocial bee. Oikos. 77:68-76.
Abstract

Patterns of demographic and social variation exhibited by the sweat bee Halictus ligatus, reveal that expression of eusocial colony organization is associated with local environmental conditions, harsher conditions promoting more classical eusociality and gentler conditions promoting diminished eusociality. We examined a variety of factors affecting body size variation of H. ligatus at a nesting aggregation near Victoria in southern Ontario, Canada during the summers of 1984, 1990 and 1991. Body size variation was associated with gender and reproductive caste as expected, and there were significant colony effects on size as well. An unexpected result was the dramatic effect of local environmental conditions on body size changes in weather pattern from year to year resulted in significant body size variation among all classes of adult sweat bees, including queens, workers, gynes, and males. In 1990 cool, rainy weather led to the production of brood with relatively small body sizes, while in 1984 and 1991, relatively dry, warm weather had the opposite effect. Weather probably influenced brood body size by affecting the ability of adult female bees to gather provisions for the larvae, and so indirectly affecting food availability to brood. Since queens are produced a year before their own workers, environmental factors affecting their relative body sizes are uncorrelated. Nevertheless, the degree of eusocial colony organization is strongly affected by variation in the relative sizes of queens and workers, and this illustrates the extent to which stochastic environmental variation strictures opportunities for behavioural interactions in primitively eusocial bees. The pattern of inverse variation between temperature and body size in this bee contradicts the general pattern of increased body size at higher temperatures generally seen in insects and other ectotherms, and indicates that social insects could be an exception to this rule.

 

A39 Pabalan, N., K.G. Davey and L. Packer 1996. Comparative morphology of spermathecae in solitary and primitively eusocial bees. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 74:802-808.
Abstract

Spermathecae of solitary and primitively eusocial bees from five major families were compared according to their chamber size, epithelial cell height (wall thickness), number and shape of glands, number of sperm pumps, and diameter of the duct, using whole mounts and serial sections. A thick spermathecal wall with a small chamber in our exemplar colletid, megachilid, and andrenid bees, a large chamber with a thick wall in social apidae, and a thin wall with a large chamber in social halictids that a big chamber may be associated with increseaed colony size. A thin epithelium in the receptacle of halictid bees suggests relegation of spermatheacal secreation to the spermathecal gland. A relatively thick spermathecal wall in th Apinae indicates the potential importance of both the epithelial cell layer of the at receptacle and the enlarged spermathecal gland in maintaining large numbers of stored sperm. There was one sperm pump in all taxa the representative Halictidae, in which this structure was paired. Elongated spermathecal glands may typify the spermathecae of eusocial bees.

 

A38 Richards, M.H. and L. Packer. 1995. Annual variation in survival and reproduction of the primitively eusocial sweat bee, Halictus ligatus (Hymenoptera: Halictidae). Canadian Journal of Zoology. 73:933-941.
Abstract

We studied a nesting aggregation of the primitively eusocial sweat bee Halictus ligatus near Victoria in Souther Ontario during the summers of 1984, 1990, and 1991. Differences in local weather patterns from year to year had marked effects on bee demography and behaviour, belying previous conclusions about "typical" social organization in this aggregation. In 1990, comparatively cool, rainy weather resulted in high nest-failure and low brood-survival rates, while in 1984 and 1991, relatively dry, warm weather had the opposite effect. In 1984 and 1990, spring nest initiation was synchronous and the emergence periods of the first (worker) and second (reproductive) broods were temporally distinct. In 1991, exceedingly warm spring weather caused asynchrony in the timing of nest initiation, accelerated brood and colony development, and continuous brood production. In 1984 and 1990, a few males were produced in the first brood but most were produced in the second brood several weeks later. In 1991, continuous brood production meant that production of males represented the transition between production of workers and of gynes (second-brood females). Patterns of demographic and social variation exhibited by H. ligatus at Victoria parallel those observed on a continent-wide geographic scale. This suggests that primitively eusocial sweat bees maintain a variety of reproductive options, adjusting their social behaviour in response to local environmental conditions.


A37 Richards, M.H., L. Packer and J. Seger. 1995. Unexpected patterns of parentage and relatedness in a primitively eusocial bee. Nature. 373:239-241.
Abstract

In species with haplodiploid genetic systems, full sisters are more closely related to each other and less closely related to their brothers, than to their daughters and sons. The classical theory for the origin of hymenoptern eusociality predicts that in many primitively or facultatively eusocial species, workers should exploit this relatedness asymmetry by laying male-destined eggs while allowing the queen to lay gyne-destined (reproductive female) eggs. This prediction is satisfied in many species where colonies are founded by solitary gynes. Here we describe a surprising reversal of the classical pattern. In colonies of the bee Halictus ligatus (Halictidae), queens produced most of the male destined eggs whereas workers produced many of the gyne-destined eggs. We suggest that this pattern may result from temporal constraints on the production of reproductive brood, and that it may be common among primitively eusocial species.


A36 Packer, L., A. Dzinas, K. Strickler and V. Scott. 1995. Genetic differentiation between two host "races" and two species of cleptoparasitic bees and their hosts. Biochemical Genetics. 33:97-109.
Abstract

In this paper we test the following two hypotheses: (1) that apparently conspecific samples of the cleptoparasitic bee Coelioxys funeraria, differing markedly in size and reared from different host species, do indeed respresent one panmicitc population; (2) that bees that nest in holes in wood or twigs have higher levels of genetic variation than those nesting in the ground. Based upon 41 loci, the genetic differences between the two samples of C. funeraria could be explained entirely in terms of sampling error. In contrast, the sympatric C. moesta showed 16 fixed allelic differences from the C. funeraria samples. Similarly, the two hosts of C.funeraria, Megachile relativa and M. inermis, had 21 fixed allelic differences between them out of 42 presumptive gene loci. Heterozygosities ranging from 0.045 to 0.054. Comparisons of heterozygosity estimates among bees remain ambiguous as to whether soil nesting confers sufficient environmental buffering effects to reduce possible advantages of heterosis is ground-nesting species.


A35 Packer, L. 1994. Lasioglossum (Dialictus) tenax (Sandhouse) (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) as a solitary sweat bee. Insectes Sociaux. 41:309-313.
Abstract

Nine nests of Lasioglossum (Dialictus) tenax were excavated near Calgary, Alberta, Canada over a time period encompassing the entire brood production period in 1988. Each nest contained a maximum of one active adult female, nest productivity peaked in mid July, protandry was noted detected. These data suggest that this species is solitary. These results are compared with data for the sympatrically nesting eusocial species L. (D.) Laevissimum.


A34 Richards, M.H. and L. Packer. 1994. Trophic aspects of caste determination in a primitively eusocial sweat bee. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 34:385-391.
Abstract

Caste determination in primitively eusocial sweat bees is thought to be due to an interacting suite of factors, including size of the larval provision mass, time of year, and social context of the nest into which a young female emerges. Newly emerged workers, suggesting the existence of larval caste determination cues. Since photoperiod, temperature, and interactions with nestmates were unlikely to affect larval caste determination, we compared the sizes and contents of larval provision masses destined to produce either workers or gynes. Gyne-destined larvae consumed pollen masses that were larger and contained slightly more sugar that those of worker-destined larvae. We suggest that sugar content is one cue with prompts the development of fat reserves in gyne-destined females but not in worker-destined females. The amount of fat possessed by a newly emerged female influences her chances of successfully entering diapause shortly after emergence. Therefore, small, lean females may be more susceptible to behavioural control by queens and more likely to become workers, while large, fat females would be more likely to become gynes.


A33 Packer, L. and R.E. Owen. 1994. Relatedness and sex ratio in a primitively eusocial halictine bee. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 34:1-10.
Abstract

Lasioglossum laevissimum was studied in Calgary, Alberta, where it is eusocial with one worker brood. Estimates of relatedness were obtained among various categories of nestmate based upon four polymorphic enzyme loci, two of which exhibited significant levels of linkage disequilibrium. Relatedness estimates among workers and among reproductive brood females were very close to the expected 0.75 value that obtains when nest are headed by one, singly mated queen. However, relatedness between workers and the reproductive brood females they reared was significantly lower than 0.75. A low frequency of orphaning with subsequent monopolisation of ovipositon by one work brood female in orphaned nests may explain these results. Workers were significantly more and queens significantly less closely related to make reproductives than expected if all males were to have resulted from queens significantly less closely related to male reproductives than expected if all males were to have resulted from queen-laid eggs. Orphaning and worker-produced males contribute to this result. The sex investment ratio was 1:2.2 in favour of females in excellent agreement with the predictions based upon relative relatednesses between workers and reproductive brood males and females. Adaptive intercolony variation in investment ratios was detected: the sex ratio was more heavily female-biased in nests in which the relative relatedness asymmetry between workers and reproductive brood was more female-biased. The study species is the most weakly eusocial hymenopteran for which relatedness estimates and sex ratio data are available. With high relatedness among nestmates and a strongly female biased sex ratio, this study suggests the importance of indirect fitness contributions in the early stages of social evolution.


A31 Li, J., I.B. Heath and L. Packer. 1993. The phylogenetic relationships of the chytridiomycetous gut fungi (Neocallimasticaceae) and the Chytridiomycota II. Cladistic analysis of structural data and description of the Neocallimasticales Ord. nov. Canadian Journal of Botany. 71:393-407.
Abstract

We investigated the phylogientic relationships of the chytridiomycota and the chytridomycetous gut fungi with a cladistic analysis of 42 morphological, ultrastructural, and mitotic characters for 38 taxa using both maximum parsimony and distance algorithms. Our analyses show that there are three major clades within the chytridiomycota: the gut fungi to the order Neocallimasticales ord.nov. Our results suggest that a modified chytridiales, including the Monoblepharidales, is a monophyletic group. In contrast the Spizellomycetales are papraphyletic because the Chytridiales arose within them. The separation of the traditional Chytridiales into two orders is thus doubtful. Although the Blastocladiales are closer to members of the Spizellomycetales than the Chytridiales, the cladistic analyes of both structural and rRNA sequence data do not support the idea that the Blastocladiales were derived from the Spizellomycetales. We suggest emendations to the classification of the Chytridiomycota and note which groupings require further analysis. Our Phylogeny for the currently recognized species of gut fungi is inconsistent with the existing classification. Nonetheless, pending further investigations, we prefer to retain the existing, easily defined genera for which a key is provided.


A30 Rosenmeier, L. and L. Packer. 1993. A comparison of genetic variation in two sibling species pairs of haplodiploid insects. Biochemical Genetics. 31:185-200.
Abstract

Sibling species pairs of sweat bees (Halictus confusus and H. tumulorum) and pine sawflies (Neodiprion pratti and N. marus) were surveyed for genetic variability using enzyme eletrophoresis. Levels of hetero-zygosity were found to be within he ranges earlier recorded for Hymenoptera. Expected heterozygosities were not significantly higher in the sawfiles than in the sweat bees. Eztimates of genetic identity between the siblings species were not lower than those generally found for diplodiploid insect species: no evidence was found for an increased rate of evolution in these haplodiploids. Genetic identity data among populations of H. confusus and between Halictus species were within the range expected for conspecific popluations and sibling species, respectively. In Neodiprion all genetic distances were low but the two populations of N. pratti had similar genetic distances as each did to N. maurus, indicating the neccessity for further systematic studies of the genus.


A29 Packer, L. 1993. Two new species of Halictine bees from high altitude in the New World tropics. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 71:1653-1662.
Abstract

Two new species of halictine bees are described. A distinctive new species from high altitude in Ecuador is described on te basis of a single male. It appears to fall within the genus Caenohalictus as presently understood, although this diverse genus is badly in need of revision and may not be monophyletic. The concept of Mexalictus is expanded to include a new subgenus, Georgealictus, which appears to be an epiponine wasp mimic with a petiolate abdomen and elongate propodeum. This new subgenus is the sister-group to the nominate subgenus of Mexalictus. Mexalictus (Georgealictus) poludbiodes is described on the basis of one male and two females, all from altitude in the state of Chiapas, Mexico.


A28 Blanchetot, A., and L. Packer. 1992. Genetic variability in the social bee Lasioglossum marginatum and a cryptic undescribed sibling species as detected by DNA fingerprinting and allozyme electrophoresis. Insect Molecular Biology. 1:89-97.
Abstract

DNA fingerprints (DNAfp) were obtained for three widely separated samples of bee related to Lasioglossum marginatum using the M13 sequence as a probe. Bee samples were obtained from France (three localities separated by at most 20 km), Greece and India. All European populations exhibited almost identical profiles with similarity indices (S) of over 98% within a French sample, 94% among Greek bees and 90% between Greek and French bees. The DNAfp profiles of Indian bees showed more polymorphism (intrapopulation S = 77%) and were quite dissimilar to the European samples (S = 55% and 56% to French and Greek samples, respectively). The similarity between populations separated by over 2000 km is higher than among unrelated individuals within a population in two other bee species and the tsetse fly. Data from allozyme electrophoresis shows parallel variation to that obtained with DNAfp and the genetic differences between Indian and European samples are strikingly large (Indian and European populations shared no alleles at 14 out of 47 loci surveyed) such that more than one species must be involved. Nonetheless, the samples are indistinguishable morphologically. We argue that chronically low effective population size in these species results in low levels of genetic variability and that this, combined with a genetic bottleneck during the speciation event and colonization of Europe, may have resulted in both the extremely low levels of DNAfp variation in European bees and the large number of fixed allelic differences between Europe.


A27 Owen, R.E., L.J. Mydynski, D.B. McCorquodale and L. Packer. 1992. Allozyme variation in bumble bees. Biochemical Genetics. 30:443-453.
Abstract

Allozyme variation at an average of 37.3 loci was assessed in queens of 16 Bombus and 2 Psithyrus bumble bee species from North America. The mean expected heterozygosity (H) for the Bombus species was 0.008 " 0.006 (95% confidence limits) and that for the Psithyrus was 0.007 " 0.007. These levels are significantly lower than found in other Hymenoptera but are comparable to those found in previous studies of bumble bees based on far fewer loci. Neutral mutation and random genetic drift can account for the observed variation, but this implies a very small effective population size for species of bumble bees.


A26 Packer, L. 1992. The social organisation of Lasioglossum (Dialictus) laevissimum in Southern Alberta. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 70:1767-1774.
Abstract

An aggregation of Lasioglossum (Dialictus) laevissimum was studied in Calgary, Alberta, in the summer of 1988. This species was weakly eusocial, with an average of less than 2.5 workers per nest, 43% males in the worker brood, 63% of workers with well developed ovaries, 35% of them mated, and a mean queen-worker size dimorphism of 7%. Based upon its average rank for these variables, in comparison with eight other species, L. laevissimum is the most weakly eusocial member of the subgenus Dialictus. Nonetheless, reproductive-brood production averaged around 25 per nest, and this species is clearly well adapted to short-summer environments. There was little evidence that any worker-brood females entered early diapause rather than functioning as workers. A few spring nests were initiated by more than one overwintered foundress. These pleometrotic nests often had worker-brood productivities that exceeded average reproductive-brood size. Brood mortality was low, infection of provision masses after rainfall being the major factor.


A25 Packer, L., R.E. Owen and C. Plateaux-Quénu. 1992. Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) mediterraneum as a species distinct from L. (E.) laticeps, with notes on its phylogenetic position. Canadian Entomologist. 124:371-380.
Abstract

We show that Lasioglossum mediterraneum (Blüthgen) (Hymenoptera, Halictidae) is a species distinct from L. laticeps (Schenck) based upon electrophoretic analysis of 39 allozyme loci for sympatric populations collected from the Dordogne region of France. The genetic identity between the two is below average for sibling species of insects: no fewer than 10 fixed allelic differences were found. In contrast, allopatric L. laticeps populations (from the Dordogne and Paris) are genetically almost identical (I = 0.998). Heterozygosity estimates for both species are low, as is often the case with Hymenoptera. Diagnostic characteristics that can be used to separate the two species are described. A phylogeny for nine species of the subgenus Evylaeus is constructed from allozyme data.


A24 Packer, L. and R.E. Owen. 1992. Variable enzyme systems in the Hymenoptera. Biochemical Systematics and Ecology. 20:1-7.
Abstract

Hymenoptera typically have low levels of allozyme variation yet genetic markers are required for studies of relatedness. Results of a survey of allozyme variation in the order are presented. Data were analysed both in terms of the proportion of times variation has been found with particular enzyme-staining systems and the average heterozygosity detected with each system. Some of the most frequently variable enzymes have not been routinely surveyed. Some possible reasons for this are discussed and some technical improvements are suggested.


A23

Packer, L. 1991. The evolution of social behaviour and nest architecture in sweat bees of the subgenus Evylaeus (Hymenoptera: Halictidae): A phylogenetic approach. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 29:153-160.
Abstract

Phylogenetic studies are required to establish the direction of evolutionary change in behavioral characters. Here I produce a phylogeny for 8 Old World species of the subgenus Evylaeus based upon cladistic analysis of 26 informative allozyme loci. By mapping behavioral character states upon the resulting cladogram, the following major conclusions could be drawn: (1) Social Evylaeus species share sociality by descent from a eusocial common ancestor which might not have been an Evylaeus species; the solitary behavior of Lasioglossum (E.) fulvicorne may be a derived condition. (2) One reversal to solitary behavior within Evylaeus is proven for a Japanese montane population of L. (E.) calceatum. (3) The perennial societies of L. (E.) marginatum are derived from an annual social cycle and do not represent an independent evolution of sociality. (4) Multiple-foundress associations are a derived condition within Evylaeus, suggesting that if social behavior evolved within the group, then the semisocial route was not the one taken by these bees. (5) The nest architectural trait of excavating a cavity around clustered brood cells is a ground plan characteristic of Evylaeus but with a reversal in L. (E.) marginatum. (6) It is likely that extended opening of brood cells during juvenile development has originated independently twice among the species considered. Another benefit of phylogenetic studies is their use in predicting which taxa are most likely to exhibit particularly interesting behavioral states. In this regard, the phylogeny suggests that close relatives of L. (E.) fulvicorne and also most of the major species groups of Evylaeus which have not received any field study should be investigated both phylogenetically and behaviorally for a full evaluation of behavioral evolution in Evylaeus.


A22 Packer, L. 1990. Solitary and eusocial nests in a population of Augochlorella striata (Provancher) (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) at the northern edge of its range. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 27:339-344.
Abstract

Augochlorella striata was studied at the northern limit of its range. The study population contained a mixture of solitary and social nest foundresses. Eusocial foundresses produced 1 or 2 workers before switching to a male biased brood. Solitary foundresses produced males first. Cells vacated by enclosed offspring were reused late in summer. A female biased brood resulted from cell reuse in both solitary and eusocial nests. Workers were slightly smaller than their mothers and were sterile although most of them mated. In comparison to published data from a Kansas population of this species, the Nova Scotia population had i) a lower proportion of multiple foundress nests, ii) a smaller worker brood and iii) a briefer period of foraging activity but iv) comparable overall nest productivity.


A21 Packer, L. and R.E. Owen. 1990. Allozyme variation, linkage disequilibrium and diploid male production in a population of the primitively social bee Augochlorella striata (Hymenoptera; Halictidae). Heredity. 65:241-248.
Abstract

A population of the primitively eusocial bee Augochlorella striata was surveyed for allozyme variation at 47 loci for 35 enzyme systems with a mean number of haploid genomes sampled of 76 per locus. The expected heterozygosity (mean " S.E.) was 0.107 " 0.004, the highest found for any bee species, solitary or social, studied to date. This result indicates that low levels of genetic variation are not ubiquitous in bees. No differences in allele frequencies between males and females were found. One diploid male was detected providing a maximum likelihood estimate of the frequency of diploid males in the population of 2.6 per cent. Strong linkage disequilibrium was detected between the loci Dia-2 and Lap. Under a genetic drift explanation for disequilibrium and realistic assumptions for the recombination rate between the two loci, the predicted population size is in broad agreement with that suggested from field studies.


A20 Packer, L. and R.E. Owen. 1989. Isozyme variation in Halictus rubicundus: a primitively social bee (Hymenoptera: Halictidae). Canadian Entomologist. 121:1049-1058.
Abstract

Halictus rubicundus (Christ) is a primitively eusocial halictine bee. Studies of electrophoretic variation at 48 loci for 37 enzymes with an average of 38 bees per locus provided an expected heterozygosity of 0.038 " 0.018 for a population from Vancouver, B.C. This value is well within the range found for other primitively eusocial bees and wasps. Comparisons of allozyme mobilities made among samples from France, Alberta and Vancouver indicated that there are some genetic differences, with the French sample appearing particularly distinct. The loci Diaph, G3pdh-1, and 6Pgd-1 had variants with both alleles at high frequency within the Vancouver population. These loci could provide good estimates of the average relatedness between nest mates.


A19 Packer, L., V. Jessome, C. Lockerbie and B. Sampson. 1989. The phenology and social biology of four sweat bees in a marginal environment: Cape Breton Island. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 67:2871-2877.
Abstract

Augochlorella striata, Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) cinctipes, Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) comagenense, and Lasioglossum (Dialictus) laevissimum were studied on Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia, throughout their flight season in 1987. The weather during the summer was unusually good, with above-average temperatures and hours of sunshine but very low rainfall. Conversely, the previous summer had been very poor for bees, with comparatively few days suitable for foraging, particularly in July. Augochlorella striata was basically solitary but some nests produced one or, at most, two workers, thereby becoming eusocial. In other localities, L cinctipes is known to be eusocial with well-developed morphological and physiological caste differentiation. However, most foundresses observed in 1987 were extremely small, smaller than usual for workers elsewhere, and none of the more than 100 nests produced adult workers or a reproductive brood. Most foundresses were either survivors of the worker brood from the previous year or unusually small reproductive brood females produced as a result of the bad weather in 1986. Lasioglossum comagenense was solitary or semisocial with one to four females occupying a nest. Lasioglossum laevissimum exhibited significant levels of pleometrosis and an extended period of worker foraging in summer. A comparison of the productivities of these four species indicates the importance of a flexible social system in a marginal climate.


A18 Packer, L., B. Sampson, C. Lockerbie and V. Jessome. 1989. Nest architecture and brood mortality in some sweat bees (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) from Cape Breton Island. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 67:2864-2870.
Abstract

The nest architecture of four species of the bee family Halictidae from Cape Breton Island, Nova Scotia, was studied. Augochlorella striata and Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) comagenense constructed their brood cells in a cluster surrounded by a cavity. In the case of A. striata, the cavity-forming habit increased the rate at which the soil of the brood cell cluster dried out, relative to the surrounding soil. The year of the study was unusually dry and in midsummer the moisture content of the soil was extremely low. This weather pattern seemed to result in some mortality of A. striata brood due to dehydration, and prevented foundresses from constructing brood cells. The two other species, Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) cinctipes and Lasioglossum (Dialictus) laevissimum, did not construct brood cell clusters. All four species had shallower nests than other species with similar nest architectures for which published data are available. All species except L. laevissimum nested in association with stones at the ground surface. It was shown that brood cells of nests situated close to rocks and stones were likely to experience increased temperature, presumably resulting in a faster developmental rate of immatures. This may be important in the Cape Breton environment, which is clearly marginal for social sweat bees. Both A. striata and L. comagenense exhibited very low mortality rates in developing immatures (1 and 7%, respectively).


A17 Plateaux-Quénu, C., L. Plateaux and L. Packer. 1989. Preadaptations to sociality in the bivoltine, solitary halictine Evylaeus villosulus. Insectes Sociaux. 36:245-263.
Abstract

The biology of Evylaeus villosulus was studied both in the field and in experimental rearing cages.

Field caught females and their summer daughters were compared using multivariate discriminant functions analysis. The variables used were two size, two colouration and four sculpturing characteristics. All variables show significant differences between generations but the colouration and sculpturing characters did not show allometric variation within generations and may be environmentally induced.

Sex ratio data are available for the summer generations for both field and laboratory reared brood. Both gave female biased sex ratios approximately 4:1. Data for the overwintering generation were obtained only for the laboratory, the sex ratio was slightly female biased 1.2:1. Pupal weights differed significantly between generations for females but not for males. Using the appropriate values, the investment ratio is female biased in both generations; approximatley 5:1 in the summer and 2:1 in the autumn.

Overwintered females frequently survive long enough to forage simultaneously with their earlier emerging offspring. Cohabitation between females of the same generation occurs with low frequency but no division of labour results, rather communal colonies are formed. Similarly, when a mother and a daughter shared a nest, an eusocial colony resulted. Thus, E. villosulus would appear to be a basically solitary species despite exhibiting reduced size in the daughters of overwintered females and a female biased sex ratio, both of which are characteristics frequently associated with eusociality.


A16 Packer, L. and R.E. Owen. 1989. Notes on the biology of Lasioglossum cooleyi (Crawford), an eusocial halictine bee (Hymenoptera: Halictidae). Canadian Entomologist. 121:431-438.
Abstract

A nesting aggregation of Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) cooleyi (Crawford) was studied on the campus of the University of British Columbia in July 1988. This species is primitively eusocial. There was a 7.3% size difference between queens and their workers; 40% of the latter had well-developed ovaries and 14% were mated. Thus, this species is one of the most primitively social members of its subgenus. The cells were not gathered together in a cluster or surrounded by a cavity. This species has a haploid chromosome number of 18, the largest number yet recorded for any Halictid bee.


A14 Packer, L. 1988. The effect of Bombylius pulchellus (Diptera; Bombyliidae) and other mortality factors upon the biology of Halictus ligatus (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) in southern Ontario. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 66:611-616.
Abstract

Two factors were important in causing brood mortality in a southern Ontario population of Halictus ligatus: parasitism by larvae of the bombyliid Bombylius pulchellus and various forms of microbial infection of bee immatures or their pollen ball food. Bombyliid larvae consumed host prepupae or, less commonly, young pupae, restricted their attack mostly to the reproductive brood, and were contagiously distributed within the nest population. All immature stages were susceptible to fungal infection or disease but such pathogens did not seem to spread among cells within nests, indicating that bees may be able to prevent the spread of disease from one brood cell to another. Filling affected cells with earth may accomplish this brood hygiene. The survival rate of worker and reproductive brood immatures approximated 90%. Reproductive brood mortality affected females more than males. Reproductive brood mortality was probably underestimated: filled-in cells that may represent brood mortality were not included in these estimates.


A13 Packer, L. and G. Knerer. 1987. The biology of a subtropical population of Halictus ligatus Say (Hymenoptera; Halictidae). III. The transition between annual and continuously brooded colony cycles. Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society. 60:510-516.
Abstract

In north temperate regions Halictus ligatus has an annual colony cycle as found in almost all other social sweat bees. However, in the extreme south of Florida, this species is continuously brooded and multivoltine (i.e., it has overlapping colony cycles with one complete cycle lasting for a few months) and the matrifilial societies exhibit a markedly reduced reproductive division of labour. Several series of collections were made along the length of Florida to determine where the transition between the annual and continuously brooded colony cycles occurs. An annual colony cycle seems to be retained at least as far south as Tampa; the continuously brooded populations are restricted to the extreme south of Florida.


A12 Packer, L. 1987. The triungulin larva of Nemognatha (Pauronemognatha) punctulata LeConte (Coleoptera; Meloidae) with a description of the nest of its host Megachile brevis pseudobrevis Say (Hymenoptera; Megachilidae). Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society. 60:280-287.
Abstract

Two single cell nests of Megachile brevis pseudobrevis are described from the Florida Keys and compared with the nests of the nominate subspecies. Both cells contained pupae of the meloid beetle Nemognatha (Pauronemognatha) punctulata. This is the first record of a larval host for this species. The triungulin larva of N. punctulata is described and a key to the first instar larvae of the subgenus Pauronemognatha is presented. Observations indicate that Borrichia frutescens is the preferred host plant for the meloid adults and it seems probable that they oviposit mostly on this species.


A10 Packer, L. and G. Knerer 1986. The biology of a subtropical population of Halictus ligatus Say (Hymenoptera; Halictidae). I. Phenology and social organisation. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 18:363-375.
Abstract

A large population of Halictus ligatus was studied in the subtropical climate of Knights Key, Monroe County, Florida. The dissection of 858 female bees caught on flowers and 420 bees from completely excavated nests gives the following picture of phenology, colony development and social organisation. In the Florida keys, H. ligatus is continuously brooded and multivoltine. However, towards the coldest time of year young gynes may rest in their natal nests rather than found a new colony. This may result in a partial synchronisation of nest initiation when warm weather returns after a particularly cold spell. Most nests are started by a single foundress that usually survives until near the end of production of reproductives. The first brood is very variable in size and males average 11% of the bees produced at this stage. This figure increases to 56% when the first brood workers begin provisioning. Queens are produced some time after the rise in male production and colony longevity is extended by the presence of some worker brood during this phase. Queens average 16% larger than their workers but appear to exert little inhibition of worker reproductivity: 57% of worker bees mate and 68% show ovarian development. This population is unique amongst social halictines in being continuously brooded, multivoltine and in having such weak physiological caste differentiation. It seems to represent an intermediate stage between the primitively eusocial colonies of H. ligatus found in temperate regions and the communal-like ones of the tropics.


A9 Packer, L. 1986. The biology of a subtropical population of Halictus ligatus Say. II. Male behaviour. Ethology. 72:287-298.
Abstract

In the subtropical climate of the Florida Keys, Halictus ligatus has a continuously brooded, multivoltine colony cycle. This results in young gynes and workers being active at all times of the year, potentially causing problems for males with respect to mate choice. Males respond to females by ignoring them, touching them briefly or by knocking them of flowers into the surrounding vegetation, where mating takes place. Over half of the females at this locality are mated although males prefer large, young individuals. Multiple mating of females does occur. Males search for females around flowers and, less commonly, near nest sites. Because females of this social insect offer varied returns to male mating effort, it is not surprising that males exhibit mate choice.


A8 Packer, L. 1986. The biology of a subtropical population of Halictus ligatus Say. IV. A cuckoo-like caste. Journal of the New York Entomological Society. 94:458-466.
Abstract

Intraspecific cleptoparasitism is described in a subtropical population of the social sweat bee Halictus ligatus. Cuckoo-like individuals are, on average, larger than workers but smaller than queens. Behavioral modifications resulting in the cleptoparasitic behavior are quite minor: forced entry and sneaky oviposition are activities possessed by non-parasitic members of this population. Only the trap-lining and host nest choice behaviors are new. Intraspecific cleptoparasitism has not been recorded from any of the temperate populations of this species that have been studied. It is argued that the continuously brooded, multivoltine phenology of this population has been a necessary prerequisite for the origin of this pattern of cleptoparasitism.


A7 Packer, L. 1986. The social organisation of Halictus ligatus (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) in southern Ontario. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 64:2317-2324.
Abstract

The social organisation of Halictus ligatus was studied at Victoria, southern Ontario. At this locality, the one worker brood has a protracted period of emergence; this results in small colony populations throughout the summer activity phase. Workers average 12.7% smaller than their queens, 60% of them have some ovarian development, and 42% of them mate. More males are produced toward the very end of the first brood than earlier in the spring provisioning phase. These late first brood males probably survive to mate with reproductive brood females. In orphaned nests, one worker dominates the others to become a replacement queen. Most replacement queens are mated and orphaned colonies produce reproductives of both sexes. Data from this population are compared with those of other studies of this, and other, halictine species.


A6 Packer, L. 1986. Multiple foundress associations in a temperate population of Halictus ligatus. Canadian Journal of Zoology. 64:2325-2332
Abstract

Thirteen pleometrotic (multiple-foundress) nests of the primitively social sweat bee Halictus ligatus were excavated in the summer of 1984 at Victoria, near Toronto, southern Ontario. Subordinate foundresses were significantly smaller than both dominant females in pleometrotic nests and females that nested solitarily. Most subordinates were smaller than the workers that they helped to raise. These small females could have been surviving workers from the previous summer or the offspring workers. It seems likely that they were malnourished reproductive brood individuals produced as a result of parental manipulation. In successful nests, the number of workers produced was positively correlated with the number of founding females such that productivity per foundress remained fairly constant. Pleometrotic nests also produced more reproductives than haplometrotic (single-foundress) ones. Subordinates may occasionally lay reproductive brood eggs. The increased productivity of multiple-foundress nests was not quite sufficient, by itself, to select for subordinate behaviour. The small subordinates had lower potential productivities in comparison to the larger females. This decreased reproductive potential, when combined with the increased productivity of pleometric nests, was sufficient to make subordinate behaviour selectively advantageous. When both factors are taken together, subordinate behaviour is selected for as long as the coefficient of relatedness between dominant and subordinate individuals is greater than ¼. This indicates that high coefficients of relatedness are not necessary for pleometrosis to be selectively advantageous under the conditions found in this study. Dominant females may suffer increased reproductive competition from their numerous workers. This, plus the difficulty of ensuring association with siblings in spring, may be the reason why multiple-foundress associations were uncommon at this locality. The data presented here are compared with those from other studies of this species. The factors promoting pleometrosis in halictines are compared with those that result in multiple-foundress associations in temperate polistine wasps.


A5 Packer, L. and G. Knerer. 1986. An analysis of variation in the nest architecture of Halictus ligatus in Ontario. Insectes Sociaux. 33:190-204.
Abstract

Nest architecture of Halictus ligatus was studied at Victoria, southern Ontario; over 130 nests were excavated in 1984. The most important findings are as follows. Nest failure was lower in vegetated areas than in bare ground. Nests with entrances hidden under leaves may suffer less mortality from parasites than those out in the open. Loops around cells are dug in response to moist soil conditions and appear to be an intermediate step toward cavity formation. Brood mortality due to mould seemed to result from cell waterlogging which the excavation of loops may help to prevent. Cells near the surface may suffer from waterlogging after heavy rains. Nests situated in denser vegetation suffered less mortality from mould. Gyne-producing cells are larger than male or worker-producing ones. Mandibular wear is an accurate measure of the amount of excavation performed by an individual female.


A4 Packer, L. and G. Knerer. 1985. Social evolution and its correlates in bees of the subgenus Evylaeus. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology. 17:143-149.
Abstract

Eleven behavioural characteristics of eight species of the subgenus Evylaeus were analysed using principal components analysis. The first component axis represents social level and explains over forty percent of the total variation in the data. The following characteristics are highly correlated with social level – (i) a reduction in the proportion of males in the first brood, (ii) a reduction in the proportion of workers that mate, (iii) a reduction in the proportion of workers that have developed ovaries, (iv) an increase in the mean number of workers, (v) increased contact between adults and developing brood and (vi) an increase in the size difference between queens and workers. Because these factors appear, in general, to be under the control of the queen it is argued that parental manipulation has been an important component of social evolution in the bees. The number of worker broods and the mechanism of male production are also related to social level but are less important. Nest architecture, nest defense, and polygyny seem to be unrelated to social level. Variation in nest architecture may be in response to edaphic features of the substrate. The lack of any relationship between polygyny and social level implies that the semisocial route to eusociality was not the one taken. It is likely that polygyny can only occur where the substrate is suitable for the winter hibernation of sisters in their natal nest. Multivariate methods are useful in determining the relative social level of closely related halictine species.


A3 Packer, L. 1985. The social organisation of two halictine bees from southern Mexico with notes on two bee-hunting philanthine wasps. Pan-Pacific Entomologist. 51:291-298.
Abstract

A nesting aggregation of Lasioglossum (Dialictus) exiguum and Halictus hesperus was discovered in the state of Chiapas, Mexico in January 1985. Both of these species are primitively eusocial with well developed morphological and physiological caste differentiation. H. hesperus has been studied in Costa Rica and Panama and details of the biologies of the different populations are compared. The social organisation of L. exiguum is compared with that of its close relative L. umbripenne. Philanthus gibbosus is recorded as a predator upon both halictine species and Trachypus gracilis preyed upon H. hesperus.


A2 Packer, L. 1984. The ecological genetics of the speckled wood butterfly, Pararge aegeria L. - A preliminary study. Heredity. 52:179-188.
Abstract

Phenologic and geographic variation in background colouration and hind wing spotting in the Satyrid butterfly Pararge aegeria are described from a study of cabinet specimens. This species has two generations in the year. The spring generation exhibits a bimodal pattern of emergence: those individuals which overwinter as pupae emerging earlier than those which pass the winter in the larval state. These early and late spring broods exhibit statistical phenotypic differences which seem to become obscured in the summer generation. Butterflies from Ireland and the South-West Peninsula are statistically distinct from those in the rest of Great Britain. A comparison between the ecological genetics of this species and Maniola jurtina is made.


A1 Packer, L. 1983. The nesting biology of Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) laticeps (Hymenoptera; Halictidae) in England. Insectes Sociaux. 30:367-375.
Abstract

An aggregation of Lasioglossum (Evylaeus) laticeps (Schenck) was discovered on the cliffs at Charmouth, Dorset, where nests were initiated in cracks in the clay soil. The cell clusters of both spring and summer broods were surrounded by a cavity which was enlarged as the number of cells increased. L. (E.) laticeps appears to have the most primitive social organisation of the four species of the L. (E.) malachurum species group for which data are available. Thus there is a high proportion of males in the first brood (24 %) and the morphological caste differences are slight: workers are, on average, 7 % smaller than the queens.