Home » Posts tagged 'Commercial Litigation'

Commercial Litigation

One Accounting, One Cause of Action? Estoppel in Patrick Street Holdings

Final judgments should end disputes, but parties need to know which disputes they were required to resolve. In Patrick Street Holdings Ltd v 11368 NL Inc, the Supreme Court of Canada barred a new argument for payment under a mortgage excluded from an earlier accounting. I agree with that result. But how can respondents know when a challenge to part of an accounting also puts their own claims at stake?

The Anti-Deprivation Rule finds its way to the SCC in Chandos Construction Limited v Deloitte Restructuring Inc

Chandos Construction Ltd v Deloitte Restructuring Inc 2020 SCC 25 (“Chandos”) explores a number of issues but the main one addresses the anti-deprivation rule and whether its application requires an effects-based test or a purpose-based test. In essence, the anti-deprivation rule does not allow contracting parties to include contractual provisions where, if one party declares […]

Vancouver Airport Authority v Commissioner of Competition: “Public Interest” Privilege Comes Crashing Down to Earth

“Privilege” is a common-law doctrine that prevents the compulsory disclosure of documents or information that is against the public interest. As Justice L’Heureux-Dubé explains: The doctrine of privilege acts as an exception to the truth-finding process of our adversarial trial procedure. Although all relevant information is presumptively admissible at trial, some probative and trustworthy evidence […]