Home » Posts tagged 'Criminal Law'

Criminal Law

R v Vrbanic : When Does Case Complexity Justify Trial Delay?

A delay of just four days beyond the constitutional ceiling was enough to halt a criminal prosecution involving 18 accused individuals. However, should a scheduling mistake in a complex prosecution prevent criminal charges from being heard on their merits? In R v Vrbanic, 2026 SCC 19 [Vrbanic], the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) considered how […]

Scaling Sentencing: R v Cope, 2026 SCC 32

The Supreme Court of Canada’s (“SCC”) recent decision in R v Cope, 2026 SCC 32 is thunder, not lightning. Their judgment demonstrates the necessity for sentencing judges to maintain harmony between responding to violence against Indigenous women, while also weighing the systemic context underpinning unlawful conduct by an Indigenous offender. Further, the SCC exemplifies how […]

Ceiling or No Ceiling? R v R.B.-C. and When Sentencing Delay Becomes Unreasonable

In R v R.B.-C., the Supreme Court of Canada was asked to apply a presumptive ceiling to determine when sentencing delay breaches s. 11(b) of the Charter. Justice Martin declined to do so, holding instead that the test is a ‘markedly longer’ standard. She also held that the correct remedy for unreasonable sentencing delay is a reduction in sentence. This unanimous decision from the Court reveals how it views judges as normative actors within the Canadian criminal justice system.

R v Nguyen: Can Property Be Forfeited After a Stay of Proceedings?

A stay of criminal proceedings ends an accused’s prosecution, but does it also prevent the Crown from seeking forfeiture of property allegedly connected to criminal activity? In R v Nguyen, 2026 SCC 10 [Nguyen], the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC” or the “Court”) considered whether the Crown could pursue forfeiture after criminal proceedings were stayed […]

Asking "What If?": Judicial Hypotheticals in Quebec (AG) v Denis, 2026 SCC 25

“What if?” is a question rooted in curiosity. Hypotheticals are a valuable tool for constitutional analysis that may allow courts to test the limits of legislation beyond the facts before them. However, balancing an individual’s Charter rights with statutory interpretation raises an important question: should there be parameters of a hypothetical scenario analyzed by the […]

“Um You Should Know What That Means”: R v Fox and Solicitor-Client Privilege

Law students typically learn about solicitor-client privilege as centred around the client. This privilege, so I was taught, ensures that clients can be frank with their lawyer; with the benefit of full disclosure from their client, lawyers can make the best case for their client. The facts in R v Fox turn this paradigm on its head: what if privilege is claimed not to protect the client, but the lawyer?

La Forest’s Corbett: Hussein and the Corbett Framework 

In R v Hussein, the SCC clarified the Corbett application. While the Corbett application has been upheld, albeit with clarifications, this Comment compares Hussein with the original R v Corbett case and argues that Hussein appears to favour La Forest J.’s Corbett dissent. 

Siloing Evidence: Rioux and Errors of Law in Crown Appeals of Acquittals

R v Rioux was crowned the “Raspberry Award” for being the worst Supreme Court of Canada decision of 2025. While the award might be in jest, the implications of Rioux certainly are not, especially for the increased possibility of the reversal of an acquittal. In my analysis, I suggest that the majority’s decision in Rioux is contrary to the SCC’s deference considerations when determining an error of law. I also suggest that the SCC has expanded the concept of error of law.