The Sociology Video Project


Find a video: by topic | by title | only the best | only Canadian  | for hearing impaired viewers

Title: The other side

Rating: 2.3 out of 4

Reference: Director & producer, Laurel Angeloff.
Winnipeg: Maple Lake Releasing, 1999.
20 minutes
Call number: video 5590

Abstract: Examines the issues that people face when someone close to them has had a stroke. Five different caregivers talk candidly about the issues and the emotional decisions they had to make, their struggles and their triumphs.


Library of Congress subjects:
Cerebrovascular disease--Patients—Rehabilitation
Cerebrovascular disease--Patients--Family relationships
Caregivers--Psychology
Caregivers--Family relationships

Sociology subjects:
The body
Disability
Health & medicine

Reviews and Numerical Ratings

2 Heartfelt, educational on issues of care-giving for those who’ve had a stroke. But little discussion of structural issues of health care, no material from perspective of people who’ve had a stroke, few sociological insights. Lecture topic: care & care-giving. Lachlan Story

2.5 Engaging people - one caregiver is a university student, well-edited, Canadian context helpful for sociology of health classes. However, accounts are overwhelmingly individual-oriented & offer only snippets of sociological commentary. Sample is all white & middle-class. Lecture topics: sociology of health, experience of illness, care-giving. Kathy Bischoping & Riley Olstead

2 This 20-minute video presents first person perspectives on care-giving for family members who experience stroke and serious illness. The narratives provide a critique of the health care system by pointing out the isolation, lack of formal supports, losses and lifestyle changes care-givers experience. While touching and emotionally powerful, the perspectives provided are those of white, upper middle-class traditional-family care-givers, and do not address issues related to the unpaid nature of caring labour, nor the gendered/raced nature of that labour. Therefore, the analysis seems quite incomplete. Susan Braedley

2.5 This video displays the struggles of not only the victims of stroke, but also of their families and friends. Loss of the ability to communicate, inability to partake in activities, hobbies and professions suffering or ending completely, are just some of the examples featured of what makes this experience so devastating for stroke victims and their close ones. It was interesting to see that the recovery process either served to strengthen or breakdown relationships between stroke victims, their family members and friends. Especially with the population aging, this video becomes more important as it is an effective display of the quality of life for stroke victims and caregivers after the stroke. However, this video is terribly depressing and sad to watch. Suitable difficulty for students at any level. Belinda Godwin


 

About the project | Book a video for class | Enter the Library Catalogue | Send us feedback | Back to main