|
Lecture Outlines January 9
"The study of politics is the study of the influential. The influential
are those who get the most of what there is to get." Harold Lasswell
"Politics is the science that teaches the people of a country to care
for one another." William Lyon Mackenzie
The course material is organized into four categories: conceptual framework;
historical overview; institutions of government and politics; provincial public
policy.
The polity is the sphere of activity in which people combine in collaborative decision-making for the authoritative allocation of values. It is
distinguishable from the economy and civil society, though it influences and is
influenced by those spheres.
Understanding the meaning of political processes and outcomes can be enhanced
if we see them in context the context of the economic, social, geographic.
cultural and historical conditions in which events have occurred and are
occurring.
- What are the economic and geographic factors of greatest consequence for
Ontario politics?
 | Size Territory, Population Geographic distance from capital,
constituency sizes, weight in national politics (rep by pop) |
 | Geographic features the Shield, Great Lakes/St. Lawrence lowlands |
 | Regionalism? North (east and west), Central, East, Southwest, "Golden
Horseshoe," GTA different histories, different economic bases |
 | Population distribution, transportation networks |
 | Economy industrial concentrations, employment, trade, wealth and
poverty, unionization |
 | Urbanization main cities, relative sizeWhat are the social factors
that condition Ontario politics? |
 | Urbanization (not just an economic influence, but also a socio-cultural
one) |
 | Ethnic and religious diversity |
 | Patterns of migration |
 | Age structure of the population (esp. Post-War Baby Boom) |
In addition to other cultural factors, is there a "political"
culture of the province? What do we mean by the term, and how do we go about
measuring it?
- Definitions Material or ideas? Microscopic or macroscopic?
Contemporary or historical?
If culture is conceived in "material" terms, it is seen in
concrete institutions; if it is conceived in terms of "ideas" it
will be measured by looking for indicators of what people believe
If culture is addressed "microscopically" it will be measured in
terms of the actions or views of individuals or small groups; if it is
addressed "macroscopically" it will be measured in terms of
society-wide features, whether ideal or material.
If culture is seen as a contemporary phenomenon, we will attend mainly to
its manifestation in the present day. If it is seen as historically grounded,
we will attend to critical points in the provinces history when the culture
was developed.
- Contents Has Ontario a culture of its own, by the definitions above?
Of what does it consist?
Are there ideas or institutions that constitute "normal" practice
of politics in Ontario? Are there values and expectations that we can point to
as stable over time and fundamental to Ontario political life?
- Impact of values on politics?
What evidence is there that political actors are motivated by values
whether in the form of culture, ideology, or even opinion?
- Why do we seek explanations in "culture?"
If we conceive of political actions as wholly determined by material
conditions, we have a number of anomalies that require explanation. We have
to acknowledge a degree of "agency" in our subjects the
capacity for independent decision-making. We presume that what people
believe helps to determine what they choose to do. The concept of political
culture is intended to reflect the degree of orderliness and stability we
sometimes find in such beliefs.
Over the next couple of weeks we will briefly review Ontario political
history. One of the most significant questions deriving from the historical
review is what has been the changing pattern of provincial state activity
i.e., what has been the scope of the provincial state and how has it changed
over time, and in response to what influences?
- Pre World War II limited scope and scale
- Post World War II expansion of welfare state with post-war federal
commitments (Marsh Report), post-war economic boom, post-war baby boom
- Urban growth
- Industrial growth
- Immigration
- Changing role of labour
- Breakdown of the post-war consensus?
- Neo-liberalism in the 1990s, 2000s
Why study the history of Ontario politics?
- Roots of some present-day conflicts can be seen in past
- Traditions beget values, expectations
- Occasionally political appeals call upon past images, events
- Historical analysis helps separate myth from fact in political rhetoric
- Knowledge of the past lends perspective to study of the present
 |