Home » Posts tagged 'Charter'

Charter

APPEAL WATCH: SCC to Look at Use of Emergencies Act to End 2022 Convoy Protests in Canada v CCLA

The Supreme Court of Canada has granted leave to appeal in Canada (AG) v. Canadian Civil Liberties Association. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld the Federal Court’s finding that the government’s decision to invoke the Emergencies Act to quell the 2022 Convoy protests was unreasonable. It also found that the emergency measures implemented under the Act violated the Charter. The Supreme Court will hear arguments on these two points as well as on the correct approach to judicially reviewing government decisions under the Act.

R v Vrbanic : When Does Case Complexity Justify Trial Delay?

A delay of just four days beyond the constitutional ceiling was enough to halt a criminal prosecution involving 18 accused individuals. However, should a scheduling mistake in a complex prosecution prevent criminal charges from being heard on their merits? In R v Vrbanic, 2026 SCC 19 [Vrbanic], the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC”) considered how […]

Ahluwalia v. Ahluwalia: How Should the Law Confront Intimate Partner Violence?

In Ahluwalia v. Ahluwalia, the Supreme Court of Canada reckoned with the largely-gendered harms of intimate partner violence. Justice Kasirer established a framework for developing new intentional torts, created a new tort of intimate partner violence to combat the distinct wrong of coercive control, and clarified the overlapping roles that tort and family law play for seeking justice and compensating victims. While the Court’s decision provided some needed clarity, it also raised as many questions as it answered, leaving unaddressed issues to be resolved in future decisions.

‘Excusez Moi?’: Language Rights in Société de l’Acadie du Nouveau-Brunswick v Canada (Prime Minister)

Language rights in Canada have a broad history. There is perhaps no province that embodies this commitment quite like New Brunswick, given its status as the only official bilingual province in Canada. In Société de l’Acadie du Nouveau-Brunswick v Canada (Prime Minister) 2026 SCC 22 [Nouveau-Brunswick], the Supreme Court (SCC) contends with applying Charter protected […]

R v Nguyen: Can Property Be Forfeited After a Stay of Proceedings?

A stay of criminal proceedings ends an accused’s prosecution, but does it also prevent the Crown from seeking forfeiture of property allegedly connected to criminal activity? In R v Nguyen, 2026 SCC 10 [Nguyen], the Supreme Court of Canada (“SCC” or the “Court”) considered whether the Crown could pursue forfeiture after criminal proceedings were stayed […]

Asking "What If?": Judicial Hypotheticals in Quebec (AG) v Denis, 2026 SCC 25

“What if?” is a question rooted in curiosity. Hypotheticals are a valuable tool for constitutional analysis that may allow courts to test the limits of legislation beyond the facts before them. However, balancing an individual’s Charter rights with statutory interpretation raises an important question: should there be parameters of a hypothetical scenario analyzed by the […]

Beyond Neutrality: Kanyinda, s. 15(1), and the Limits of Facial Equality

In Quebec (Attorney General) v Kanyinda, the SCC considered whether the provincial subsidized childcare regime of Quebec violates the equality rights guaranteed under s. 15(1) of Charter. Karakatsanis J., writing for the majority, held that the provisions of the Reduced Contribution Regulation that excluded refugee claimants from eligibility to participate in the subsidized childcare program created adverse effects discrimination based on sex. Although facially neutral, the legislative scheme disproportionately impacted and burdened female refugee claimants, who are more likely to bear the primary burden of childcare responsibilities.

APPEAL WATCH: SCC to Determine the Use of Compelled Accident Statements in Korduner

The Supreme Court of Canada has granted leave to appeal the decision in R v Korduner, a split decision from the Alberta Court of Appeal that examines the extent of use immunity for statutorily compelled statements. In particular, the SCC may wish to examine whether a statement given by a motorist who has an honest and reasonably held belief that they are statutorily compelled can be used as the reasonable grounds necessary to compel an evidentiary breath test pursuant to s.320.28 of the Criminal Code.