Home » 2008 (Page 5)

Abortion Debate Revisited as Morgentaler receives Order of Canada

On Friday, October 10, 2008, abortion-rights activist Dr. Henry Morgentaler, received an Order of Canada award at a ceremony at the Citadel in Quebec City, Canada. In 1969 after immigrating to Canada from Poland, Morgentaler, a family physician, opened his first clinic in Montreal where he performed thousands of at-the-time illegal abortions. He was arrested […]

R v Patrick and the Lingering Significance of Property in Section Eight Charter Jurisprudence

Almost twenty-five years ago, Chief Justice Dickson famously proclaimed in Hunter v Southam, [1984] 2 SCR 145 [Hunter], that s. 8 of the Charter “protects people not places.” In so doing, Dickson CJ dislodged property as the primary safeguard against unlawful search and seizure, supplanting it with a vaguely defined notion of a “reasonable expectation of […]

Only One Civil Standard of Proof: FH v McDougall

Civil cases involving allegations of criminal or morally blameworthy conduct, such as sexual assault against minors, carry social stigma that go beyond other types of civil disputes. Until very recently, the approaches of U.K. and Canadian courts in addressing the burden of proof in such cases have varied; in general, they tended to apply the […]

Did Banks See the Forest for the Squeegees?

More than a year has passed since the Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") dismissed the application David Banks, et al v Her Majesty the Queen, [2007] 156 CRR (2d) 376 (SCC) [Banks] for leave to appeal on August 23, 2007. By dismissing Banks did the SCC implicitly endorse the criminalization of poverty? Admittedly, the SCC receives far […]

Security Certificates and Filtered Disclosure: Applying Charkaoui #2

On September 24, 2008, Judge Simon Noël of the Federal Court ordered the Canadian Security Intelligence Service ("CSIS") and the Ministers of Public Safety and Citizenship and Immigration to “file all information and intelligence related to Mohamed Harkat including but not limited to drafts, diagrams, recordings and photographs in CSIS’s possession or holdings with the designated […]

Privacy and investigative dumpster diving: R v Patrick

The Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") will hear arguments this Friday on yet another major s. 8 Charter issue in the case of R v Patrick, [2009] 1 SCR 579 [Patrick]. Recent decisions of the top court on police search and seizure powers have been complicated by deep divisions within the court, as evidenced by the four-way […]

When are a Trial Judge's Reasons Sufficient?

Last Thursday the Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") decided on two companion cases, R v REM, [2008] 3 SCR 3 [REM] and R v HSB, [2008] 3 SCR 32 [HSB], both of which concerned sexual abuse convictions that were overturned on appeal on the basis that the trial judge’s reasons were inadequate. In both instances the SCC reinstated the […]

Aboriginal Property Rights "Down Under"

Since I am currently "down under" visiting Sydney, Australia, I thought that this may be a good opportunity to look at a case that is presently before the Australian High Court involving Aboriginal property rights. The former Liberal federal government, lead by John Howard, implemented a compulsory five-year intervention program in the Northern Territory whereby […]