Home » 2008 (Page 6)

Tercon Heads For Supreme Court Showdown

The Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") recently granted leave to appeal in Tercon Contractors Ltd v British Columbia (Transportation and Highways), 2007 BCCA 592 [Tercon]. The British Columbia Court of Appeal’s ("BCCA") controversial decision in Tercon raises a fundamental question: If the courts take a “hands-off” approach to tendering infractions, who will protect the integrity of the bidding […]

R v LTH – Subjectively Objective? Objectively Subjective?

The Supreme Court of Canada's ("SCC") ruling in R v LTH, [2008] 2 SCR 739 [LTH], while a welcome one for defenders of criminal justice rights of young offenders, is one that invites comment upon the SCC's continuing interest in promoting objectivity in decision of law – even where an objective standard may not reasonably exist. […]

MT v J-YT: Injustice Measured in Economic Terms

Le Patrimoine Familial In Québec, the family patrimony is established immediately upon marriage or civil union of two persons. The principle behind the family patrimony is that a marriage creates an equal legal and economic partnership between two individuals; therefore, when their partnership ends – whether by divorce, separation, annulment or death – they are […]

Double-Dipping: the New Reality

Over the last decade or so, the lines separating the fields of telecommunications and broadcasting have become harder and harder to distinguish. This convergence has lead to difficulties in determining the applicability of laws to activities enabled by new technologies. On September 18, the Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") refused leave to appeal in Canadian […]

All Hail to the Jean: Governor General Reportedly Intervenes for Khadr

The Globe and Mail and Toronto Star have recently commented on reports that Governor General Michaëlle Jean advised the Prime Minister to repatriate Omar Khadr. The original story appeared in La Presse on September 26, 2008. It must be emphasized that the veracity of these reports remains to be seen. However, if true, they raise […]

Do Canadians Have a Right to Information under the Charter?

Introduction This season’s Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") docket promises yet another round of exciting and potentially ground-breaking judgments. One case in particular, however, holds the promise of drastically changing the contours of Access to Information legislation in Ontario and beyond. Tucked away in the SCC’s December schedule, Ministry of Public Safety and Security (Formerly […]

When does freedom of the press cede to investigating crime?: R v National Post

The Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC") is set to decide whether confidential sources for newspaper reporters are entitled to a claim of privilege similar to that of confidential police informants. The case of R v National Post, which received leave to appeal this morning, will settle a long-standing grey area in Canadian media law, but to […]

Patent Rights and "Public Order"

In Harvard College v Canada (Commissioner of Patents), [2002] 4 SCR 45 [Harvard College], the Supreme Court of Canada ("SCC"), in a 5-4 decision, ruled that a genetically modified mouse was not a patentable invention under the Patent Act, RSC 1985, c P-4. Harvard College had created a genetically modified mouse, known as the “oncomouse,” that […]

The Supreme Court of Canada: A Court of International Renown

The New York Times recently published an article on the waning international influence of the U.S. Supreme Court, especially with regard to constitutional law. As countries like New Zealand (whose Bill of Rights was enacted in 1990) and South Africa continue to develop jurisprudence around their young constitutional documents, they are looking increasingly less at […]