Skip to main content Skip to local navigation
Home » Definitions & Key Considerations

Definitions & Key Considerations

When developing a new course, revising an existing course, or reviewing a program's overall delivery model, academic units and instructors are encouraged to use the selection criteria in this guide to identify the most appropriate mode of delivery. The criteria support decisions that align with York University's approved delivery modes and advance both course-level and program-level learning outcomes.

Delivery mode decisions should be considered within the broader context of program design and curricular coherence, recognizing that the mix of delivery modes across courses contributes to the overall student learning experience and achievement of program outcomes. Because some criteria may apply to more than one delivery mode, they should be considered collectively rather than in isolation.

In-person, blended and online modes of course delivery are the most common at York and so were selected to frame the guidance below. The advantages, disadvantages, and key considerations provided by York instructors across each of these modes offer valuable insights and support the application of the selection criteria. Definitions of each mode and suggested language for communicating expectations to students through course notes are also provided to support a fuller understanding of each mode at York University. Together, this information can help determine which mode(s) of delivery are appropriate for a course and program context before applying the selection criteria to inform the final decision.

In-person (LECT, and others): Course activity is designed to take place in a physical classroom, laboratory, studio or other assigned, designated learning space on a York campus. Contact hours occur face to face to facilitate real-time interactions and hands on experiences. 

  • Note 1: Remote delivery is the term for unplanned virtual learning during an in-person-designated course in emergency circumstances, or where the normal campus space/access is temporarily unavailable. Remote learning is not a typical mode of delivery. 

  • Note 2: In-person activity may occasionally be replaced with a virtual experience, based on a specific pedagogical rationale or to accommodate a particular learning experience that can only be offered online (e.g., a guest lecturer from another time zone). This must be communicated to students in advance.

The Modes of Delivery Working Group Report identified key opportunities, challenges, and considerations for each mode of course delivery.

Mode of DeliveryAdvantagesDisadvantagesKey Considerations
In-personEngagement and real-time feedback were cited overwhelmingly as key benefits to an in-person mode, where the ability to interpret student reactions allowed for immediate adjustments to teaching approaches, and where student participation was more dynamic. Community and connection result from relational teaching practices, such as informal conversations, a shared sense of belonging to a group or cohort and are critical in first year courses and in discussion or studio-based courses, for example.Regular attendance in in-person courses, despite students’ reported preferences for in-person learning, is observed to be low. Barriers of accessibility and flexibility were also cited for York’s largely commuter student body and in relation to life balance.In-person delivery may be important where community, cohort belonging, discussion, studio-based learning, or academic assessment of course outcomes are central. In-person delivery may support more accurate academic assessment of course outcomes by meaningfully limiting the use of AI, cheating and other forms of academic dishonesty."

Suggested language for courses ‘Notes’ option:

"This course is delivered primarily through in-person learning activities that require regular attendance on campus. Course information, learning materials, assessments, and communications may be provided through eClass or other online tools. Course outline and eClass site will include details regarding course delivery, assessment methods, and participation expectations."

Blended (BLEN): Course activity is intentionally designed to take place via in-person and online instruction, using a designated learning space on a York campus and a digital/computer-based platform, in a space selected by the student. Blended modes are comprised of a set number of in-person and online (synchronous or asynchronous)  contact hours, and this composition must be communicated in advance to students, ideally at the time of enrolment.  The mix of modalities is purposefully planned by the instructor to facilitate and align with various aspects of learning and student achievement of learning outcomes.

  • Note 1: The term 'hybrid' has been used interchangeably with 'blended'; it is recommended that only ‘blended’ be used for consistency in communication of this mode and that ‘hybrid’ be no longer used. 

  • Note 2: The use of the courses' 'Notes' option, available on the Search Course Timetable website, may include information for students about the blended schedule (e.g., in-person lectures, online synchronous tutorials, etc.).

The Modes of Delivery Working Group Report identified key opportunities, challenges, and considerations for each mode of course delivery.

Mode of DeliveryAdvantagesDisadvantagesKey Considerations
BlendedActive learning and deeper engagement were cited as pedagogically related advantages when in-person time is directed towards discussion, application, problem-solving, and hands-on, higher-order learning. Flexibility may also support access by reducing commute times and supporting self-paced content.Flexibility supports access but not always learning. Student self-regulation is needed for success, particularly in asynchronous activities that place greater emphasis on engagement and independence. Reduced interactions may affect achievement of learning outcomes.Design intentionality is the deciding factor for success. Each modality should be purposefully aligned with specific course learning outcomes, where stronger achievement of outcomes is reported.

Suggested language for courses ‘Notes’ option:

"This course includes both in-person and online components. Online components will be delivered [synchronously/asynchronously]. Course outline and eClass site will include details regarding course delivery, assessment methods, and participation expectations."

Online (ONLN): Course activity is designed to take place virtually using a digital/computer-based platform, in a space selected by the student. All contact hours occur virtually and may be scheduled as synchronous (students and instructors interact simultaneously, in real time) or asynchronous (unscheduled with no simultaneous interaction; self-paced).

Online, Campus-based Assessment (ONCA): Most course activities are designed to take place virtually using a digital/computer-based platform in a space selected by the student, except for certain course components such as tests and exams. This distinction for attending campus for scheduled tests, exams, or other assessments must be clear to students at the time of enrolment. These in-person components may be scheduled for a time other than the regularly scheduled class time. 

  • Note: The use of the courses ‘Notes’ option may include information for students regarding when the in-person assessments will take place (day of the week, time).

ONCA is coded separately from ONLN because, while both are primarily online delivery modes, ONCA includes required in-person assessments on campus. This distinction must be visible in the lecture schedule so students know at the time of enrolment that they will need to attend campus for scheduled tests, exams, or other assessments. Separate coding also allows the Registrar’s Office to schedule ONCA courses appropriately, including any required rooms, dates, and times for campus-based assessments.

The Modes of Delivery Working Group Report identified key opportunities, challenges, and considerations for each mode of course delivery.

Mode of DeliveryAdvantagesDisadvantagesKey Considerations
OnlineFlexibility and accessibility were main criteria for teaching online, where barriers related to students’ financial and life challenges may be minimized. Self-paced learning and independent review opportunities for motivated students support better achievement of course learning outcomes in this mode; for students who may struggle academically, this is a disadvantage.Disengagement occurred as evidenced by lowered participation, less active communication, and a compromised sense of community. There is also poor capacity to conduct reliable online assessment due to AI; at York, ONCA is recommended by some instructors as a response to this issue.Synchronous and asynchronous modes are distinct forms of virtual course delivery in terms of planning, learning, and student engagement. Pedagogical legitimacy remains unclear for instructors, with online experiences ranging from genuinely effective and valued to damaging to institutional reputation.

Suggested language for courses ‘Notes’ option:

  • Online Synchronous: "This course is delivered fully online with live virtual classes on [day(s)] at [time(s)]. Course outline and eClass site will include details regarding course delivery, assessment methods, and participation expectations."

  • Online Asynchronous: "This course is delivered fully online with no scheduled class meetings. Students complete course activities and assessments independently by established deadlines. Course outline and eClass site will include details regarding course delivery, assessment methods, and participation expectations."

  • Online, Campus-based Assessment (ONCA): "This course is delivered primarily online. Students are required to attend campus for [assessment type(s) and frequency] scheduled on [date(s)/timing, if known]. Course outline and eClass site will include details regarding course delivery, assessment methods, and participation expectations."